Baylor > Social Work > News

Top News
•  Dr. Jon Singletary Recognized with VCU Making a Difference Alumni Award
•  Dr. Gaynor Yancey Receives Achievement Award
•  Crisis Intervention Team from Baylor Receives State Award for Volunteer Efforts in West
•  Gift from Leader in the Care of Aging Adults Establishes Endowed Chair in Baylor's School of Social Work
•  Special Fall Worship Service to Be Held in September
•  Baylor University to Hold Rethink Mission Conference in September
•  Waco Downtown Farmers Market Accepts SNAP Benefits
•  SSW Seeks to Fill Three Faculty Positions
•  Baylor, the SSW and Waco Create New Waco ISD Position to Aid Community
•  Baylor-hosted Hunger Summit Digs into Roots of Poverty
•  SSW names Kentuckian as Alumna of the Year
•  The Weight of the World: GML Cover Story in Baylor Magazine
•  Hogg Scholars Announced at Baylor's School of Social Work
•  Military Family Coping Project Receive Funding for Phase II of Research
•  GML Initiative moves ahead thanks to generous gift
•  THI kicks off No Kid Hungry statewide campaign
•  Baylor School of Social Work welcomes alumni from Carver School
•  Baylor grad uses art to capture hunger issues
•  Ministry Seeks to Share God's Love with Strangers Among Us
•  Social Work Alum Wins Spirit Award
•  "You Are What You Eat" Photo Exhibit at School Open House
•  A Conversation with Tanya Smith Brice
•  Looking to find your center of creativity? Unplug
•  Fridges Speak Volumes

Social Science or Proselytizing?

April 23, 2009

It may not matter how clearly social workers explain informed consent to recipients of social services in a religiously affiliated organization - not if the recipients believe getting food to feed their family depends on their agreeing to an explicit or implicit religious message. That's the finding of a study published in the April issue of Social Work: Journal of the National Association of Social Workers (Vol. 54, No. 2, pp. 157-165) co-authored by three Baylor School of Social Work professors.

The intersection of faith, social services and professional ethics has always been a slippery slope, and according to the findings in "Innovative Service or Proselytizing: Exploring When Services Delivery Becomes a Platform for Unwanted Religious Persuasion," there are good reasons for the social work profession to be concerned about its footing regarding this issue.

"If clients are in such a desperate position that they equate being selected for

services as a part of their sustenance for survival, the context of desperation and unequal power calls into question the degree of consent that is possible," said Michael Sherr, assistant professor and lead author of the article. Co-authors are Jon Singletary and Robin "Rob" K. Rogers, associate professors.

The authors present an in-depth case study of a stand-alone non-deno-minational nonprofit agency that collaborates with congregations to establish spiritual families in a midsize city. The agency employs six social workers, all of whom have independent clinical licenses.

The study provides additional support to the perspective that the discomfort some social workers have with religion may have more to do with a justified concern about providing ethical practice and less to do with a hidden agenda to eliminate any influence of religious involvement in social services, the authors state.

"The role of spirituality in clients' lives was not even addressed in social services until relatively recently," Sherr said. A few articles in the 1980s set forth the possibility that social workers should at least recognize and appreciate spirituality as a component of client functioning. An article in Clinical Social Work Journal in 1985 (Vol. 13, pp. 198-217) urged the profession to include spirituality as a major factor of individual, family, and community functioning.

Since the passage of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996, with its "charitable choice" section, more and more social service provision is provided through religiously affiliated organizations. As a result, the social work profession finds itself navigating these waters with very little literature on the subject to guide its course.

"The Baylor School of Social Work is known for its integration of faith and professional social work standards, and we need to continue to address these issues so that we can gain further insight into how this manifests itself in the workplace," Sherr said.

The Baylor authors say that their study further emphasizes the need for more substantive and broader research, but they conclude with guidelines for ethical social work in religious organizations:

• clarify roles up front

• avoid opportunities for unethical practice

• acknowledge the potential for unethical practice

• create a mechanism for ongoing confidential review with clients

"We need to both appreciate the efforts of religious organizations to address social problems and provide services," Sherr said, "but also recognize the power differentials involved in these relationships, intentionally or unintentionally, and maintain the integrity of professional helping relationships."

To purchase the full article online, visit the NASW web site at:

oberon.naswpressonline.org/vl=881646/cl=31/nw=1/rpsv/cw/nasw/00378046/v54n2/s7/p157

Author contacts:

Michael Sherr, Michael_Sherr@baylor.edu, 254-710-4483

Jon Singletary, Jon_Singletary@baylor.edu, 254-710-4819

Robin "Rob" K. Rogers, Rob_Rogers@baylor.edu, 254-710-4321