Baylor Students Try to Solve Real-Life Teaching Problems Through Research

Danielle LaCoste
Danielle LaCoste courtesy of Baylor Photography.
April 15, 2014

Follow us on Twitter: @BaylorUMediaCom

Media contact: Tonya Lewis, (254) 710-4656

WACO, Texas (April 15, 2014)—Which is better for learning — small groups or full-classroom instruction? Does individual teacher attention really improve a struggling student’s reading? How do you get rambunctious boys to behave?

Those were just a few of the questions that Baylor School of Education (SOE) seniors tackled as part of the 2014 Action Research Symposium. After designing and implementing research projects in the classrooms where they are teaching as full-time interns, 100 Baylor seniors presented their findings on April 1.

The teaching interns worked with mentor teachers in their classrooms to develop and implement the research, and many of those mentors were on hand at the Symposium, along with school principals and the superintendents from area districts.

Senior intern at Connally Elementary Alexa Samuel researched a question that Principal Nina LeBlanc suggested. She studied the difference in learning provided by whole-class instruction or small groups working at stations.

“In one class, I did only small groups, and in another I did whole-group instruction for four straight weeks,” Samuel said. She gave a pre-test and a post-test and took notes during the four-week fifth-grade math unit on measurement.

While she found little difference in the overall results, there was a big difference depending on the particular math topic. “Anything having to do with area or perimeter did better in groups, and I think it was because they had been exposed to it before,” Samuel said. “But I would want to test that out more.”

Senior Danielle LaCoste also studied small groups of fifth graders; she was an intern at River Valley Intermediate in Midway ISD. LaCoste measured both test results and confidence level through two different kinds of groups. In one classroom, she paired high-achieving students with mid-level ones and mid-level ones with lower achievers. But in the other room, she paired students of similar abilities.

While all students gained confidence, LaCoste found that mixed groups provided more learning. In the mixed-ability groups, LaCoste said, “The higher-level students really stepped up into the teacher role, and as they explain the subject, they learn more.”

LaCoste said she frequently assigns partner work, so she studied something she was curious about. That’s the point of the Action Research Symposium and the reason it’s called “The Science of Wondering,” said SOE dean Jon Engelhardt, Ph.D. — for students to pursue something they are wondering about.

“Action Research is a form of professional development,” Engelhardt said. “You don’t depend just on a workshop offered by the school district. You are your own best professional development manager, and you do that by studying your own performance, asking questions and wondering about something. Then try to answer that question with good experiments, comparisons or close observations.”

Doug Rogers, Ed.D., associate dean for undergraduate studies in the SOE, said the research project is a capstone experience for seniors. “Action research is the essence of what we expect of them as professionals — to study their own practice,” he said.

While many students conducted whole-classroom experiments, Stephanie Limes at Hillcrest Professional Development School (PDS) in Waco ISD focused on individual students with reading problems to see if her attention would make a difference. One student, who had limited English proficiency, sounded like a proficient reader, Limes said.

“He had voice inflection and intonation,” she noted, “but it was really hard for him to recall the facts.” After Limes spent one-on-one time with him and provided incremental reading goals, his content recall improved, she said.

Limes’ mentor, third-grade teacher and Baylor doctoral candidate Bianca Ochoa, said this student is an avid reader now. “He was doing everything to look like he was reading, but now he is really a reader,” she said. “And it just gives you chills.”

A couple SOE interns zeroed in on classroom problems dealing with boys. Senior Jenna Zerebny, who taught at Spring Valley Elementary in Midway ISD, said that upon entering her first-grade classroom, “The first thing I noticed was the large amount of talkative boys.”

So Zerebny designed a seven-week study to see if “brain break” activities would improve the boys’ behavior. She alternated weeks providing a short three-to-five-minute activity or not providing it. “I found that taking at least one brain break per day both increased the engagement of the students and decreased the negative behavior,” she said. “I also saw that it improved as we went along; I got better at it.”

Senior Kevin Sikes, an intern at Robinson High School, also noticed a negative dynamic among some boys in his classroom. “Every class has it — the buddies who want to sit together,” he said. So Sikes created a seating chart that put the five boys in opposite corners of the room. “On average, grades went up 12.9 percent after the seating chart change,” he said. “So we’ve been using the seating chart ever since.”

ABOUT BAYLOR UNIVERSITY

Baylor University is a private Christian university and a nationally ranked research institution, characterized as having “high research activity” by the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching. The university provides a vibrant campus community for approximately 15,000 students by blending interdisciplinary research with an international reputation for educational excellence and a faculty commitment to teaching and scholarship. Chartered in 1845 by the Republic of Texas through the efforts of Baptist pioneers, Baylor is the oldest continually operating university in Texas. Located in Waco, Baylor welcomes students from all 50 states and more than 80 countries to study a broad range of degrees among its 11 nationally recognized academic divisions. Baylor sponsors 19 varsity athletic teams and is a founding member of the Big 12 Conference.

ABOUT BAYLOR SCHOOL OF EDUCATION

The Baylor School of Education is accredited by the National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education and consists of four departments: Curriculum and Instruction (preparation for classroom teachers and specialists); Educational Administration (post-graduate preparation for school leadership); Educational Psychology (undergraduate and graduate programs for those who are interested in learning, development, measurement, and exceptionalities); and Health, Human Performance and Recreation (preparing for sport- and health-related careers, athletic training and careers in recreational professions, including churches).The School of Education enrolls more than 1,000 undergraduate students and 300 graduate students, employs 70 faculty, and is one of the few school s in the State of Texas that offers a yearlong teaching internship.

Looking for more news from Baylor University?