A Baylor Law School team went 5-0 in oral argument rounds to become champions at the ABA Regional Appellate Advocacy Competition, which was held the last weekend in February in San Francisco. With the win, the team automatically qualified for the national finals, scheduled for early April in Chicago.
The Baylor team of Brittney Johnson and David Schlottman won oral rounds against teams from Cal Berkeley, Golden Gate Law School, Northwestern, Phoenix School of Law, and Minnesota. In the final round against Minnesota, Johnson and Schlottman won all five ballots by an average exceeding 20 points per ballot. Johnson also was named the sixth top oral advocate in the regional competition.
Another Baylor team of Kathryn Childress, Molly Hinshaw, and Jose Magana also performed impressively at the regional competition and were narrowly defeated, 3-2, by one of the stronger teams in the tournament, a defeat that effectively eliminated them.
"The ABA competition is considered the most significant moot court competition in the nation, in terms of both the quantity and quality of the teams," said Baylor Law Professor Brian Serr, who served as coach. "I want to thank each of our advocates for so impressively representing Baylor Law School."
This year's competition problem brought up questions about whether restrictions on commercial speech designed to keep certain information about pseudoephedrine products from methamphetamine cooks (who use pseudoephedrine in the unlawful production of meth) violate the 1st Amendment rights of the buyers and sellers of such cold and allergy medicine products.
The problem also dealt with the propriety of judicial review when a law has not yet been enforced against the lawful sellers of pseudoephedrine products.
This is the second Baylor Law team to win an ABA regional competition in 2011. Baylor Law's ABA Client Counseling team also won its regional competition and will compete in the national tournament March 11-12. Moot Court team member Brittany Johnson also is a member of the client counseling team.